EASTER HOURS
PLEASE NOTE:Our store will be CLOSED this Easter Sunday, March 31st. We hope everyone has a wonderful holiday with family and friends!
Welcome to Plato's Closet
Middletown
Most Wanted!
Most Wanted! We're on the lookout at our buy counter for these items : Lululemon, Nike, Graphic Tees, Athletic Shoes, New Swimwear, Sandals, + Hoodies ​Stop by and sell today! We're open Monday - Saturday 10am-9pm / Sunday: 11am-7pm. There's no appointment needed!
Get paid today!win $100 to lulu!
ATHLETIC SELL A THON
On your mark, get set, GET PAID Now through April 30, get paid cash on the spot when you sell us 3 or more of Alo, Nike, or Lululemon athletic wear items, and get entered to WIN $100 to LULULEMON! *See store
We were on The Today Show!
SERIOUSLY!
We still can't get over being on The Today Show! They cover where to find BTS selections during supply shortages and rising inflation. Spoiler alert: We're one of the hot places to shop! Take an inside look at how our business is run, and meet our Co-Owner Laila, and local thrift-guru Sara! While inflation and supply shortages run amuck, Plato's Closet - Middletown NJ has thousands of styles to choose from at low prices that don't change!
GET REWARDED
We love points. We love them so much that we give you some each time you shop or sell at our stores. All you have to do is sign up for the rewards program! Once you do it, youll forever have access to exclusive discounts, promotions and events. More points, more fun! OR BY TEXTING - PCMIDDLE to 578-277 Standard message and data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel or HELP for help. Go to fivestars.com/terms for terms and privacy.
Sign up online